It’s like Christmas!
And I’d say Santa Holland did well to deliver. The Wings diversified their current core of prospects, knocking out virtually every need for players that need to be replenished in the Detroit system. We got a goalie, we got tough guys, big guys, skilled guys, and guys that are mixes of all of those things.
Detroit really flexed it’s scouting muscle, picking two OHLers, one USHLer, one from the Swedish J20 league, one Quebec-born player playing prep hockey in New York, and one player from Division 1 (third-tier) Sweden. That translates to one goalie, one defenseman, and four forwards.
Education and persistence are key. Detroit selected three college-bound players who’s rights they hold on to for longer than major junior or European league players. They also selected three players that were eligible for last year’s draft. Safe to say Detroit had their eye on some of these guys for a long time.
1ST ROUND
Tom McCollum
Goaltender … 6′2″, 205 lbs … December 7, 1989 … Amherst, New York … Guelph Storm (OHL) … 51 GP 91.4% 2.50 GAA 4 SO
CSB: 1 NA G | ISS: 2G | McKeen’s: 25 | THN: 38 | TSN: 24 | RLR: 43
Detroit set up their goaltending for the future by acquiring a third potential starting netminder, Tom McCollum, ranked first or second by most publications for goaltenders, but not drawing as much first round interest as the likes of Jacob Markstrom, Jake Allen, and Chet Pickard. McCollum was one of the best goalies in the OHL last year and continued his strong pace this year. Jimmy Howard will get the chance to backup Chris Osgood, but McCollum is good insurance in case Howard or Swedish sensation Daniel Larsson hit a wall in development. Some say Detroit could have added a skilled forward here, but I ask you when Detroit has ever been a team who can’t find skilled forwards in the later rounds. We needed a goalie, and rather than waiting until the later rounds for “depth” Detroit went for the home run.
STRENGTHS: McCollum plays a butterfly style and excels at making his already big body look even bigger, cutting down angles and smothering rebounds. TSN’s Bob McKenzie said that McCollum probably has the quickest glove hand of the draft. He’s quick and could perhaps get even quicker if he sheds a little weight like Jimmy Howard did, as the two are nearly identical in size during their draft years. He moves quickly in his crease and minimizes his movements, conserving energy. He is a pretty consistent goalie when he gets going, and is great coming out of the crease to challenge shooters when he’s confident. Very calm, very humble, and very personable.
WEAKNESSES: Some say he’s inconsistent because he had a bad start to the season, but I think that has to do more with him not playing on a very strong team that wasn’t playing very well. He generally is the same goalie from night to night. If there are any substantiated knocks on him, it’s that he’s not all that great of a puckhandler and he has trouble finding loose pucks at his feet in scrums. He can get pretty unorthodox in those situations, despite being almost as technical as they come, which makes sense since he grew up a Sabres fan and saw a lot of Dominik Hasek. I’m putting this in the weakness section for a reason.
FUTURE: McCollum is headed back to the OHL for a third season, at the very least. He’s already being talked about as a candidate to be traded at the deadline should Guelph ice a bad team again, since he carries the team on his back with almost no help. He should be a lock for Team USA’s U-20 team this December but sometimes the selection committee doesn’t take too kindly to American players who play junior hockey in Canada and not with the USA National Development team. After that, it’s very flexible. McCollum is a late-birthday, meaning although this was his first year eligible, he was born after the September 15 cutoff date so most players of his birth year were taken last season. This means that McCollum can turn pro after one more year in the OHL or Detroit can leave him one season after that without needing to sign him. Ideally, in two years Osgood will retire and Howard and Larsson will run the show in Detroit. McCollum will develop for three seasons in Grand Rapids and take over for whichever Detroit goalie isn’t performing, or, be a valuable, tradeable asset for Detroit.
3RD ROUND
Max Nicastro
Defenseman … 6′2″, 189 lbs … March 2, 1990 … Thousand Oaks, California … Chicago Steel (USHL) … 58 GP 6-14–20 78 PM
CSB: 90 NA
Max Nicastro wasn’t on the map from a lot of scouting services, but I actually had Detroit taking him in a mock draft I did. Not much reason behind it behind Nicastro being a physical defenseman. Now that he’s been taken and I’ve read more about him I like the pick much better. I believe Nicastro is the first California-born player taken by Detroit and I know he’s the first player born in the 90s. Scary thought. His favorite player is Nick Lidstrom and he says Scotty Bowman is one of the people he’d most like to have dinner with.. which is something he got to do with the rest of the Detroit picks just today.
STRENGTHS: Nicastro is a rarity in the Detroit system. He’s a big, physical defenseman. He’s more in the mold of a defensive defenseman but skates extremely well. He’s a hard-worker and excels on the penalty kill. He possesses a big, hard shot, making him a candidate for the powerplay. Defensively he is as sound as they come, combining his mobility with his physicality to eliminate forwards a variety of ways. An option as a puck-rusher if he’s confident enough. Plays against opponent’s top lines and for the most part came out as an elite shutdown defender
WEAKNESSES: The reason I bring up confidence is because Nicastro is not that great of a puckmover. He’s criticized for making poor decisions and could be a better passer. He still rushes the puck and I think if he’s confident enough he can do it at other levels because of his speed. He plays on the powerplay right now but will need to become a better passer to do it in college and in the pros.
FUTURE: Nicastro’s got an enticing future ahead of him. With college players, you hold their rights until they graduate, so, four years. Nicastro is actually going to stay in the USHL for one more season so that means Detroit will hold his rights for 5 years, until 2013. Nicastro is raw but he shouldn’t be by that time. He’ll play again for the Chicago Steel, hopefully getting stronger and better offensively. For whatever reason, he considers himself finesse and says he patterns his game after Lidstrom, so hopefully he can get in touch with his offensive soul. He will join Boston University in 2009. Welcome to the team kid, you’ll be on the prospect rankings for a long time.
4TH ROUND
Gustav Nyquist
Left Wing … 5′10″, 169 lbs … September 1, 1989 … Halmstad, Sweden … Malmö J20 (SWE-JR) … 24 GP 11-20–31 20 PM
Unranked
Gustav Nyquist is the off-the-board Swede we’ve come so accustomed to. He was eligible for last year’s draft but passed over, and unranked in this one although I had heard of him and most Swedes expected him to be selected. Nyquist is the skilled forward I said Detroit could find in the later rounds, making up for taking a goalie in the first round.
STRENGTHS: Nyquist is all offense. He’s got big league speed and an exceptional all-around skater. He has a quick wristshot and he’s a good passer, making him more of an all-around offensive player. He’s creative and fans love watching him play every night. He’s got good hockey sense, which seems to be the common denominator in which Detroit picks do the best.
WEAKNESSES: I can’t really find anything about his defensive game or play away from the puck. He’ll need to add some weight to his frame but not too much. He also spent some time this season injured, so hopefully nothing will bother him this season. Getting bigger will help him out, as it seems the injury was a back injury and a stronger back would do him well.
FUTURE: Nyquist, who is Swedish, is actually headed to the University of Maine next season it seems. He debated between playing with his club in the Allsvenskan or heading out to play college hockey. Should he become a Black Bear, Detroit will hold his rights for four years and will certainly find a time to fit him in.
5TH ROUND
Julien Cayer
Center … 6′4″, 186 lbs … July 6, 1989 … Longueuil, Quebec … Northwood School (NY-HS) … 38 GP 24-32–56
CSB: 123
Just when I thought they couldn’t go any further off the board after Nyquist, I met Julien Cayer. After going undrafted last year, he was actually ranked by the CSB but I’d never heard of him, meaning that yet again I failed to meet my goal of knowing every player Detroit takes before they take them. Cayer was born in Quebec and opted not to go to the QMJHL. He played junior A in Quebec last season before coming this season to New York to play high school prep hockey. His school is very exclusive and prestigious, putting out such NHLers as Mike Richter and Tony Granato. They play the top prep teams on the east coast and a few games against teams in the EJHL, a junior league based mostly in the New England area.
STRENGTHS: Cayer actually attended the draft and was interviewed on the NHL Network shortly after being picked. He said Detroit told him they liked his speed and skill and he’s said to have an oustanding shot — fast and accurate. He only recently grew into his frame so he’s got little man skills in a big man’s body. Going for a big home run with this pick. He seems to have a good head on his shoulders and took a smart path to the NHL. During his interview he just kept saying all the right things about doing whatever it takes to go to the NHL and he will turn pro whenever Detroit wants him to.
WEAKNESSES: Obviously I don’t know much else about Cayer. Detroit sees him as a power forward so he’ll need to get stronger and heavier, although he will have plenty of time to do so.
FUTURE: Another college-bound forward. He’ll be attending Clarkson with 2007 7th round pick Bryan Rufenach. Cayer’s older brother just graduated from Clarkson and he was a fan favorite. Clarkson fans seem very excited to be getting Julien and think he could be a great offensive player for the team.
6TH ROUND
Stephen Johnston
Center … 6′1″, 175 lbs … February 24, 1990 … Guelph, Ontario … Belleville Bulls (OHL) … 56 GP 2-5–9 12 PM
CSB: 101
I might be more excited about any pick in the draft. To the untrained eye, Johnston is an average sized center who only scored two goals this year. But look a little deeper. Johnston played on one of the deepest teams in the league, Belleville, of which it was an accomplishment enough to see regular playing time. He reminds a lot of scouts of Shawn Matthias and rose onto the rankings late in the season, fittingly, when he replaced an injured Shawn Matthias on the top scoring line. I’m not saying Johnston will replace the loss of Matthias, but he’s certainly in a very similar situation.
STRENGTHS: This season Johnston played a physical, energy game. He only scored two goals in the regular season but five in the playoffs when called upon for injuries. Scouts noticed and think he has the offensive ability to produce in the OHL next season as his team is losing a lot of veterans. Johnston’s also pretty big. He’s 6′1″ and lanky, and could probably reach about 6′2″ when he fills out. Big, hard-working, physical, two-way player. Sounds a bit like Matthias to me.
WEAKNESSES: No guarantee he breaks out next season, leaving a very puzzling pick here. Like Matthias, his offense might not translate well to the NHL. At best he could be a two-way second liner. But he seems almost a pretty safe bet for the third or fourth line if he scores next season like he did in the playoffs this season.
FUTURE: Most certainly headed back to Belleville for this season and next. Not to keep bringing up Matthias, but he’s in a very similar situation where he didn’t come on until the end of the season. The difference is Belleville was much worse in Matthias’ draft year, so he got more playing time and was forced into his role. Johnston just had no were else to play besides the fourth line. He’ll get that playing time next season and plays the hard-working style that so many Detroit prospects have. I think it’ll be a short time before he’s recognized as a steal.
7TH ROUND
Jesper Samuelsson
Center … 5′11, 179 … June 13, 1988 … Stockholm, Sweden … Vita Hästen (SWE-3) … 40 GP 20-42–62 73 PM
Unranked
Samuelsson was taken, unranked, being passed over in two different drafts, 2006 and 2007. One pick away from being passed over in a third. The similarities to two Red Wing home runs are remarkable. In 2000, Detroit took a 5′11 forward playing for Timra 210th overall — Henrik Zetterberg. In 2008, Detroit took a 5′11 forward who just signed with Timra 211th overall — Jesper Samuelsson. In 2002, with the last pick of the draft, Detroit selected a forward from Vita Hästen of the Swedish Division-1 — Jonathan Ericsson. In 2008, with the last pick of the draft, Detroit selected a forward from Vita Hästen of the Swedish Division-1 — Jesper Samuelsson. But let’s not get carried away just yet.
STRENGTHS: Pretty much everything on his EliteProspects page is all that’s available. “A player that has, a bit in the dark, put up excellent numbers in the Swedish third tier league. Samuelsson is a good skater with decent puckhandling. He has very good hockey sense and is good at delivering the puck. Looks confident with the puck and is valuable with the man advantage.” He’s also 20 and pretty filled out already, though he could get bigger.
WEAKNESSES: Samuelsson played at a low level of hockey this year. Actually, he played for his club in Swedish Division-1 (third-tier) for four straight seasons. Raw wouldn’t even begin to describe him. He didn’t get the proper development of most other Swedish prospects did in junior league systems with sproadic time on senior league teams. Also, I must mention, his last name is Samuelsson. This is a weakness.
FUTURE: Samuelsson has finally been discovered. After four years in Division-1, Samuelsson has signed a two-year deal with Timra in the SEL starting next season. He can hopefully be an impact player right away for them but that’s a big jump. Essentially from a very good beer league to the best league in Sweden. He could get loaned out to an Allsvenskan team for more playing time. But if he sticks with Timra, there’s no doubt that he’s a player.
—————
So there they are, the six newest Red Wings. Six players which hopefully in the future, can make NHL fans everywhere wonder how such a good player slipped to Detroit a la Franzen and Filppula this season, likely Jonathan Ericsson next season, and so many Wings in the past. But you’ve read this, so you know. I am very happy with this draft. We got a couple home run picks lined up and most of them are going to college, so Detroit will have them around for a while.
The Wings addressed some major needs and did so without further overcrowding their system. I’ll definitely dig around for more on some of these guys and put it up on here if it’s of interest.
Bring on 2009. Possibly the best draft in 15-20 years. This is one you will not want to miss.